Skip to main content

"Occasional Failures Are the Price of Outstanding Wins" - Rick Rule on Portfolio Discipline & More

MiningStockEducation.com Sep 4, 2026 45:33

Summary

Bull-market arrogance peaks with newcomers — Rick argues the least experienced participants are usually the most confident (mistaking luck for skill).

Limit your portfolio to stocks you actually study — his 'Amalgamated Aardvark' anecdote shows why understanding each holding matters more than its count.

Sentiment extremes mark turning points — he bought silver when social media dismissed it as 'Buggy Whips' and sold once the love returned.

Junior mining mergers stall when management self-interest blocks deals — a clean process like G2/G Mining can align incentives and get them done.

Skip speculative categories without precedent — deep sea mining fails his 'probabilistic NPV' (net present value) test, so he still prefers established Rio, Glencore, and BHP.

Key points on Agnico Eagle Mines

  • Rick Rule mentions that Agnico Eagle recently bought Orion Resources, completing a deal many had expected five years earlier to involve Rupert Resources instead.
  • He cites the Agnico-Orion transaction as a real-world example of a junior mining M&A deal that did happen, in contrast to deals that didn't.

Key points on Barrick Mining

  • Rule recounts that Barrick ultimately bought Arequipa Resources for $1 billion, 19 months after the company had been valued at just $30 million.
  • He ties the purchase to David Lowell's drill program that turned a small gold target into an 8-million-ounce deposit.

Key points on G Mining Ventures

  • Rule calls G Mining's acquisition of G2 Goldfields a smart strategic deal where the buyer recognized it had to have the deposit.
  • He says G Mining signaled to G2 that the more they de-risked the project (e.g., advancing permitting by three years and growing resource confidence), the more G Mining would pay.
  • Rule argues G Mining paid a full price rather than trying to steal the deal, given the shared shareholder base across both companies.
  • He notes G Mining structured a sidecar/spinoff for the G2 team so they had 'life after death' after the transaction closed.

Key points on Newmont

  • Rule traces Newmont's lineage to a Glamis acquisition of Francisco Gold, noting the acquirer's stock doubled on that deal despite skepticism that Glamis lacked growth.
  • He uses the Glamis-Francisco-Newmont chain as an example of how prospect-generator work can compound into much larger corporate outcomes.

Key points on G2 Goldfields Inc

  • Rule credits G2's team for running a deliberate process that created competitive tension by potentially selling a partial interest to a third party.
  • He says G2 advanced permitting by roughly three years and grew resource confidence before the G Mining deal, lifting the price G Mining was willing to pay.
  • Rule argues G2 did what they had to do by accepting a full price, since many G2 shareholders were also G Mining shareholders.
  • He notes G2 walked him through their thinking at PDAC without sharing material non-public information, which he treated as a sign of quality management.

Ross Beaty's takeaways

  • Top takeaway Rule argues Ross Beaty's two-decade persistence on the alumina geological concept made him a natural backer of what became Lumina Metals.
  • He explains the alumina project was initially locked in a joint venture with an insurance company, and once that partner was shaken out, he invested repeatedly.
  • Rule contrasts his willingness to sell one of Beaty's earlier companies before Beaty was 'done' with it, illustrating discipline over loyalty in following a thesis.
  • He credits Beaty's continued work on a project as proof that 'occasional failures are the price you pay for outstanding wins.'

Robert Friedland's takeaways

  • Top takeaway Rule defends Robert Friedland's reputation for arrogance as partly a deliberate selling technique and partly real confidence.
  • He notes Friedland publicly acknowledges mistakes, citing Galactic going from $0.10 to $20 to zero, and Quartz Mountain (his third effort) also going to zero.
  • Rule calls Friedland 'absolutely brilliant' and says he uses every tool at his disposal, including the appearance of arrogance, to build companies.
  • He uses Friedland's track record as evidence that even serial winners experience failures, reinforcing the need for honest post-mortems by investors.

Rick Rule's takeaways

  • Top takeaway Rule's overarching lesson from grading roughly 100,000 resource portfolios over 35 years: the biggest sin is investors owning too many companies they don't actually understand.
  • He warns the most dangerous arrogance in a bull market comes from retail investors who confuse rising prices with brains.
  • Rule describes his silver trade: he bought when the metal was hated (citing 'What a moron' comments on older interviews) and sold in January when the chart went parabolic.
  • He announces a 'Pitch Rick' product - a $5,000 half-hour recorded pitch where successful issuers gain access to a 10,000-person list.
  • Rule lays out his media-brand model: giving away free education to build trust, then selling branded conclusions through a paid newsletter.

Bill Powers's takeaways

  • Top takeaway Powers observes many attendees at Rule's symposium hold too many positions, including one with 100 companies and a full-time job.
  • He describes a recent pitch call where the CEO failed to appear on Zoom and the IR rep turned out to be a '90s email-scraper,' leading him to refuse the stock.