Skip to main content

Live Q&A with Rick Rule and Steve Barton

Rule Investment Media Aug 7, 2026

Summary

Rising price is not the same as rising value; resource cycles typically run years, so time preference matters as much as entry timing.

Focused copper producers like Southern Copper deliver more leverage than diversified majors such as BHP or Rio Tinto treat copper as a side business.

Resource category confidence (measured and indicated versus inferred) and on-site infrastructure matter as much as headline ounces when comparing deposits.

Royalty and streaming businesses reward patient capital over years; the next big deals will likely syndicate into bite-sized opportunities for tertiary players.

Asymmetric exploration bets work only when the loss is affordable, with Rule framing NG Energy as a possible ten-bagger against a 30 to 50% loss.

Key points on Buenaventura Mining

  • The speaker notes Buenaventura is cheaper than Pan American Silver, but warns that concentrating silver exposure in Peru adds political-risk concentration.
  • He flags this valuation argument alongside Fresnillo as a key reason some investors prefer those names despite the political risk.

Key points on Fresnillo

  • The speaker notes Fresnillo is cheaper than Pan American Silver, but warns that concentrating silver exposure in Mexico adds political-risk concentration.
  • He flags this valuation argument alongside Buenaventura as a key reason some investors prefer those names despite the political risk.

Key points on Pan American Silver

  • The speaker, a holder, argues PAAS effectively owns its Argentina and Guatemala deposits for free, together representing at least a billion ounces of high-grade silver, and that restarting either would double current production.
  • He is nearly certain both deposits will eventually return to production because governments will need mining revenue, even though local political opposition currently makes it too painful to overcome.
  • He praises recent management decisions — the Tahoe and Yamana acquisitions and reinvestment of cash into previously-neglected assets rather than milking them for dividends — as inuring to PAAS shareholder benefit.
  • He concedes Fresnillo and Buenaventura are cheaper, but prefers the total package at PAAS — corporate culture, asset quality, and management he knows personally — over a lower multiple in a single-country jurisdiction.
  • He frames PAAS as a long-duration call on political normalization in Argentina and Guatemala, with the outcome (production restart) effectively certain in his view even if timing is uncertain.

Key points on Aya Gold & Silver

  • The speaker has AYA at a 5 rating — high — but says the stock has run up so much it is starting to price in 18 months of successful execution that has not yet occurred.
  • He praises management as superb implementers with high asset quality and credits a prior Rule Classroom interview with helping force a short-covering rally he describes as a religious experience for the shorts.
  • He is a self-described huge Benoit LaSalle fan, having invested with the CEO for nearly three decades, but calls the current valuation expensive.
  • He argues that if the team executes against the feasibility study the way they historically did at AYA and before that at SEMAFO, the current market cap will prove more than justified.

Key points on Fortuna Mining

  • The speaker has Fortuna at a 4 rating and considers it cheap even after accounting for political risk.
  • He was initially skeptical of the pivot from small high-grade South American underground mines to large West African open-pit operations, but credits the Gubnosa family for adapting well.
  • He says execution has been superb since the strategy shift.
  • He flags that Ivory Coast is still a political-risk jurisdiction and is unsure whether it is qualitatively better than Bolivia or Colombia.

Key points on AbraSilver Resource

  • The speaker has AbraSilver at a 4 rating and calls it a big deposit that is getting bigger, with multi-phase geology allowing drill results to confirm an anticipatory thesis rather than merely probe for new mineralisation.
  • He frames the recent large financing — which some shareholders saw as dilutive — as the capital needed to finish the exploration stage and reach a feasibility study.
  • He warns investors should expect a boring Lassonde-curve period between the roughly $50 million exploration spend and mine construction, during which drill-related news flow will slow for about 12 months.
  • He says investors unwilling to hold through that quiet period should size their position around the next 12 months of news flow rather than the longer feasibility-to-construction arc.

Key points on Franco-Nevada Corp

  • The speaker cites Franco-Nevada's roughly 51% return over 30 years as the original success story that gave rise to today's third-tier royalty companies.
  • He warns that most investors lack the 30-year patience required for that kind of compounding, which is why most market participants missed the original FNV run-up.

Key points on Gold Royalty Corp

  • The speaker currently has no formal ranking on GROY and is reviewing it alongside Uranium Royalty.
  • He notes the market responded well to a recent Sweetwater land-package deal that lifted the stock from about $2.56 to over $4, though he does not commit to a view on the name.

Key points on Wheaton Precious Metals

  • The speaker cites Wheaton alongside Franco-Nevada as one of the two original royalty/streaming success stories whose performance spawned today's third-tier royalty space.
  • He expects Wheaton's balance sheet to be unable to absorb the next wave of very large corporate-development streams alone, which will force large syndications involving the mid-tier names.

Key points on Banyan Gold Corp

  • The speaker argues Banyan's 7–8 million ounce gold deposit at roughly 0.8 g/t deserves a similar market cap to Freegold's 30 million ounce deposit because Banyan's ounces are far more thoroughly drilled (measured and indicated) with a road through the site and Yukon grid access.
  • He contrasts Banyan's infrastructure advantages — road access and proximity to the Yukon power grid — with Freegold's truly frontier positioning.
  • He expects Banyan will have to start with on-site GenSets for power, with the industry hoping the Canadian taxpayer will fund tying the Yukon grid into the BC/Alberta grid to solve the power challenge.
  • He suggests that as exploration continues, Banyan-type deposits often reveal higher-grade chutes or cores within the broader low-grade envelope — a potential upside that Freegold has not yet demonstrated.

Benoit La Salle's takeaways

  • Top takeaway The speaker describes Benoit LaSalle as a high-quality human being and a superb implementer, and says he has invested with him for nearly three decades.
  • He frames LaSalle's prior track record at SEMAFO and current work at AYA as evidence that the AYA market cap will prove more than justified if the team executes against the feasibility study.

Steve Barton's takeaways

  • Top takeaway Steve Barton hosts the Q&A from Rule Classroom Plus, curating subscriber questions across precious-metals and macro topics and steering the discussion between Rick and the audience.
  • He contributes light editorial commentary — for example, on the improving political backdrop in Colombia and Venezuela — and uses the close to flag upcoming Rule Classroom guests and stock-chart sessions.